The streets in downtown Durban and Johannesburg were filled with protesters when I was there, and now Cape Town, too. South African unions love their strikes (like the French), but this is big partly because some of the ANC’s core constituencies are turning against it. I think it shows how distant the ruling party has gotten from its formative ideology. Plus the recession - the recession has drastic repercussions here that you wouldn’t see in the States.
The Unexamined Life
Patrick Baker is a nineteen-year-old student at Duke University. In his spare time he enjoys reading and fig newtons, but never both at once.
Back in Cape Town
…and it’s incredibly green and overcast and feels like coming home. Pictures to come, once I get back Stateside where there’s free internet, along with synopses. It’s been a pretty great week and a half.
Guess who’s coming to dinner (in Khayelitsha)
It was a week ago I was standing outside Manenberg Primary again, rushing my goodbyes as usual, then getting onto a bus full of Norwegian students. The reason for this was that the Vanderbilt team (who I’d been riding back with) had left over the weekend – our side of Manenberg threw an impromptu party the Friday before to mark the occasion, with much hugging and gift-giving and the requisite fanfare. Vince grilling pork sausages behind a row of classrooms, older kids I’d never seen biking up to ask if there were any leftovers, construction-paper diplomas for the sixth-graders. When I came back after the weekend it felt like the set of a stage production that’s just been struck: school about to resume, my boys kicking a ball around in the yard, back to usual.
Then I said goodbye. I was there to do a few more interviews and also to work on developing an idea which I’ve been hammering out with a few of the teachers. This is a program which partners Manenberg Primary with its counterpart middle school in Durham, NC, connecting students and teachers – many of the teachers here are in sore need of training and certification. I’ve been trying to pitch the idea to the people at Duke who work with local schools; they seem to think it’s promising. Could be I was just acting out an urge to see something tangible come out of the past eight weeks, to be remembered in Manenberg for something lasting. We want to be remembered, we Americans, we need those little reassurances that yes, your time here has been valuable in a more-than-monetary sense. We come to places like this for emotions and relationships beyond the scope of business transactions.
I realize that I’ve barely scratched the surface here, either talking about the point of my work in South Africa or in trying to understand the contradicting layers of Cape Town. Manenberg, after all, is a small township, only around 80,000 people, notable for the amount of bad press per capita during the time of the gang battles but relatively unknown to the wider dynamics and currents that move the city. It’s kind of well-off compared to the vast outlying townships, which are Xhosa-speaking and culturally worlds away. But hey, it’s as good a place to start as any.
Urban theorists like Mike Davis estimate that by the year 2050, the majority of the planet’s population will be living in urban slums like the ones on the Cape Flats, or on the hillsides of Rio de Janeiro. This is a totally believable statistic but it almost defies comprehension when you start contemplating it at the human level.
I think I began to grasp the implications of this prediction the following night, Thursday, when I went to Khayelitsha for dinner. A little explanation is probably needed here. A friend of mine, part of a group of students I’d met at the guesthouse, was living with a homestay family in K-ville for two weeks as part of her program. We met near the bus terminus and took a packed minibus taxi out to the fringes of the Cape Flats, where goats wandered untethered on the highway shoulder and smoke rose from oil drums. My friend’s homestay was in Harare, one of Khayelitsha’s more established neighborhoods, near a brightly-muraled community park. We sat down on a bench here as the sun went down, two white kids in scruffy attire, and the children gradually approached. They gathered around us and sat in my lap and wanted to arm-wrestle. They’d never seen me before and never would again. I got the feeling I was stepping into an intimate and closely-bound community that was welcoming me with open, well, arms. There were murals everywhere, wall-high Mandela faces and AIDS ribbons, exhortations against drugs and domestic abuse, simple expressions of neighborhood pride.
Everything in Khayelitsha is on full view: steal something from a neighbor and it is instantly tacked to your reputation on the street, nothing secret for long. There is no such thing as garbage here, or at least the line is less distinct. Things you’d throw away in the city get used here to patch up corrugated walls or collect rainwater. There’s a KFC somewhere in Khayelitsha, make no mistake, but there’s also the woman who boils goat heads on the path outside her house. The goat head lady was a few doors away from my friend’s homestay. Her host mom, a woman who peppered her English with “my angel,” “my babies,” “my baby angels,” etc., cheerfully invited me to stay for dinner, generous helpings of rice, potatoes, sweet cabbage, and mutton. They had a TV by the portable space heater, playing Dr. Phil at low volume. I stayed to help with the dishes a little and then the family walked with me to the minibus stop. This is one of the things they tell you to avoid at all costs in South Africa, take public transportation in a township at night, alone, but at this point I was still reeling from the force of the host mom’s goodwill and felt this sort of protective aura bubbling up around me. I got a few looks. The taxi stopped several times to pick up people headed downtown and once swerved to avoid something burning in the middle of the road.
The last guy I interviewed in Manenberg was a police officer, a city patrolman downtown who spends his off-duty hours watching out for the kids on his block, opening his house to them if it keeps them away from the drug dealers. Ten years ago he took his family out of Manenberg, moved into a middle-class neighborhood somewhere in the leafy suburbs of Cape Town. He lived there for eight years and then he moved back to Manenberg. I asked him why and he gestured around like it was self-evident. Which it was, in a way – the neighbors coming in to borrow cookware, kids popping in and out every few seconds from the street, things you notice because they don’t really happen in more affluent parts of town. The new neighborhood was too private, he told me, it was too secure and self-contained. Eight years and he still didn’t know the kids’ names next door. So he came back to Manenberg, drawn by the living force of this community at the margins.
Getting on the bus
I was going to make a post about my last few days in Manenberg (as well as an unexpected visit to Khayelitsha), but that’ll have to wait. There are more pressing concerns. Tomorrow, I dive with the sharks.
And this is but the first leg in a road trip I haven’t put nearly enough forethought into. Could be epic, could be poorly executed. We’ll see. On Sunday morning, after a stay in a small whale-watching haven two hours from Cape Town, I get on the “Baz Bus,” which caters to low-budget backpackers and student travelers, and get off at any one of like 30 towns and cities along the way. I’ll end up in Johannesburg, at any rate, in a little over a week.
I envision myself doing basically a lot of hiking and finding interesting places to read books, which the latter is probably easier said than done. Here is an extremely tentative itinerary I put together with some help from a backpackers’ place down the road:

July 18: Shark cage diving to Hermanus
July 19: Hermanus to Storms River
July 20: Storms River to Port Elizabeth
July 21: Port Elizabeth to Chintsa
July 22: Chintsa
July 23: Chintsa to Coffee Bay
July 24: Coffee Bay to Durban
July 25: Durban
July 26: Durban to Northern Drakensberg Mountains
July 27: N. Drakensberg
July 28: N. Drakensberg to Johannesburg
July 29: Johannesburg
July 30: Johannesburg to Cape Town
Updates, it goes without saying, will be far and few between. (Actually, they’ll probably be more frequent than the past month or so.) Pictures eventually, when I see my laptop again.
The secret lives of photographs
Monday was my last day working at Paul Weinberg’s archive. I haven’t spent much time on this aspect of my week because it’s mostly your standard entry-level intern work, scanning photo negatives and digitizing them, putting together captions for upcoming exhibitions and printing high-res glossies for the archive’s clients. A few weeks ago I was doing a set for the Jewish Museum, big prints of South Africa’s Jewish rugby legends.
But anyway – Monday I was hunting down captions for a collection of Paul’s, “Then and Now,” an anthology of eight South African photographers’ work before and after 1994. At some point I found myself staring at this image, which can be found in various iterations around the office, taped to the wall by my computer or buried under draft paper.

I often scrutinized this picture, which had struck me from the first with its precise formal arrangement and museum atmosphere. The shifty nervousness of the kids’ glances, the way they don’t really seem to inhabit the spotless room with its gleaming surfaces, the way the mother’s head is haloed, Byzantine-style, by the plate on the wall behind her. The mother looking peaceful, maybe a little resigned, her housekeeper’s broom leaning against the left frame.
I’d looked at the photograph and thought about its sense of balance and known nothing about the lives huddling behind it. Because I found out yesterday that this was a family carrying AIDS all down the line. The picture was taken in June 1999; by May of 2000 the mother and both sons were dead. Posing in her employer’s living room one last time. It’s unnerving, isn’t it, how much more arresting the photo is once you know the context.
Fighting boredom with science
It is interesting how some people are nostalgic for a state that systematically discriminated against them.
Mostly the older Manenberg residents of course, mostly women too, but the sentiment is there. Today I interviewed an 81-year-old woman who couldn’t understand why people raised such an uproar when they were forced out of District Six. This is a woman who, with her twin sister, quietly moved out to a flat in Manenberg when the nice European gentleman came knocking on her door and said they were redeveloping the neighborhood. She told me that to be honest, she preferred the apartheid government to the messiness of the present. At least then they had respect for women and the doctors were competent.
What was I going to say? It was like interviewing my own grandmother.
Even the former activists, the ones who burned tires and marched, threw rocks into the windows of white storefronts – even in these voices there are notes of displaced longing. For many of these guys, political conviction was tightly bound up with gangsterism, which explains in part their scorn and anxiety when they talk about today’s Manenberg youth. Kids are turning into hoods out of boredom and apathy and not an impassioned sense of dispossession, a rejection of structures predicated on injustice. Though who knows how many of the old guard really and truly understood the historical tide they must have felt themselves caught up in? This is the tricky part of my work, tracking down folks who saw that the marching and window-smashing would never, in themselves, suffice.
Friday I accompanied SHAWCO and the Vanderbilt contingent on an apathy-fighting mission. We were taking the Manenberg Primary kids to a science center located in Canal Walk, which a weathered sign out front states is The Largest Shopping Center in the Southern Hemisphere. It was pretty much all Michael Jackson over the speakers inside.
They swarmed over the turnstile and headed for the interactive exhibits, probably terrifying the older white guy there by the gyroscope with his grandkids. It didn’t really matter that the laws of buoyancy, of conductivity and magnetism were still largely over their heads. This was the most fun I’d had in Cape Town. There was something gleefully subversive about the whole thing, bringing these township kids here and setting them loose on mallgoing society. I’ll miss them, especially the five boys I tutor, problem children yes, but undeniably endearing at age eleven-twelve. A UCT student volunteer told me this is totally an American response - forming sentimental attachments to the kids you work with.
In which I almost get to judge an Afrikaans spelling bee
Speaking of the homeless population, let me tell you about one of the eeriest scenes I’ve run across in Cape Town. There’s this mall in the center of town – the Golden Acre shopping center – that isn’t quite as ritzy as the one at the Waterfront, though it is equally vast, with staggered walkways so you can see three levels down into the earth. On the weekend, then, it’s unlocked, but none of the stores are open on Sunday. I went in looking for something to eat, and saw whole families of homeless camped out on the dim floor. It was creepy.
There are lots more people at Manenberg Primary who I couldn’t do justice to in a single paragraph – there’s “Auntie” Shirley, an incredibly wizened volunteer, who I’m not convinced has a last name. Vince, the band leader and former gangster turned community spokesman. There’s Mr. Emmanuel, a one-time Marxist agitator who wants to study for an advanced degree in the States. Two men named Ismail – one of them almost never speaks and the other writes poetry, supposedly. I was confused about this.
“Call me Ismail,” the one who talks said. “We call that one Miley.” Ismail took me to see his mosque, a tranquil place where white-bearded men were kneeling in shafts of sun.
Last Wednesday I was asked to come out to the Manenberg library for a local reading competition between the township’s primary schools. Cyril suggested that I’d be able to sit in as a guest judge or something. But I hadn’t realized that half of the competition would be in Afrikaans, which should have been obvious – it’s most of Manenberg’s first language.
So I, along with two Norwegian students working with SHAWCO, just watched the thing unfold. Each participant was asked to read aloud a passage from Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban – which I knew what they were saying, Afrikaans or no – and then answer questions and spell words from the text. Between the Afrikaans and English rounds, the emcee, Vince, called the Norwegians and I up to the stage to say a few words about the importance of reading. I tried not to screw up. These kids can smell the insincerity rolling off you.
NB: The Afrikaans spoken in mostly colored townships like Manenberg isn’t quite what white Afrikaners like Gerda speak – it’s vaguely creole, with a status comparable to that of African-American Vernacular English.
caught my eye because I visited the Winelands last weekend. Call me a philistine but I don’t think I’ll ever really appreciate the subtle art of wine tasting. Sure, I could feel the flavors dancing on my palate. Unfortunately, I had no idea what they were. Choice excerpts from the article:
“[H]e added: ‘At tastings, they talk each other into a frenzy. It’s like the Nuremberg rallies of Hitler. If one of them picks up the taste of apple, the other guy says, “Yes, yes, and I taste cinnamon too.” ‘
Ms. MacQuitty, one of those critics, considers such comments ostrichlike: ‘Unless the South Africans track down this burnt rubber taste, they will never be a real New World player in wine.’
… These wines, she wrote, were not only ‘watery’ and ‘grassy,’ they were ‘evil.’”
Seen on the way home
- Three guys talking in equal parts Afrikaans and English about the late Michael Jackson
- A Tamboerskloof homeowner delivering a vicious, profanity-laced beating to a homeless guy who’d apparently been camped out on the front step
